No Subscription, No Contract: How Pay-Per-Check Pricing Works for Multi-Location Employers
How pay-per-background-check pricing works across many locations, how prepaid packs compare with contracts and monthly minimums, and how to budget for each store.
standard employment reports
Invite a candidate, they verify their ID on their phone, and you get a national criminal report. Flat price, nothing monthly.
Get started See pricingIn this article
If you run eight, twenty, or eighty locations, you probably don't know what a background check really costs you. One store hires every week. Another hires twice a quarter. A third is opening in a new state next spring. If your screening vendor bills on an annual contract or charges a monthly minimum, the slow stores pay for checks they never run, and nobody at the home office can say what screening costs per hire.
Paying per background check fixes most of that. You pay when a candidate is screened and at no other time. This article covers how pay-per-check and prepaid-pack pricing work across many locations, how they compare with annual contracts and monthly minimums, how to split the budget by store, and what to check in each state before you roll a single process out to every location.
You should finish with a pricing model you can choose today, a budget formula for each location, and a rollout checklist your area managers can follow.
Key takeaways
- With pay-per-check pricing, cost moves with hiring. A store that hires nobody this month costs you nothing for screening.
- Annual contracts and monthly minimums charge for capacity. When volume swings by store and by season, unused capacity is lost money.
- Prepaid packs lower the unit price without locking you in. At PreHireBadge, the $1,000 pack works out to $5 a check, compared with $10 one at a time.
- Pay centrally and order locally. One account, one shared balance, and a role for each location manager keeps spending visible.
- Pricing is the easy part. Screening rules differ by state and city, so confirm each jurisdiction before you standardize.
Why does pricing structure matter more for multi-location operators?
The more locations you run, the more your hiring volume varies from store to store, and fixed pricing models handle variation poorly. A single store can guess its yearly check count. A portfolio of stores in several markets can't, at least not per store.
The franchise sector is still growing, so many operators are adding units, and every new unit adds an uncertain hiring curve. The International Franchise Association, the industry's trade group, projects in its 2026 Franchising Economic Outlook that franchise establishments will grow from 832,521 to 845,000 units, a 1.5% increase, and that franchise employment will rise by more than 150,000 jobs (1.8%) to nearly 8.9 million. Those are the trade group's forecasts, not measured results, but they point one way: more units and more hiring, often in markets the operator hasn't worked in before.
A new unit's first month usually looks nothing like a mature store's year. Opening crews hire in a burst, and then hiring settles into a replacement pace. A contract sized for your total portfolio averages all of that together and hides it. Per-check pricing shows it, because each check is a separate charge you can trace to a location.
This article is part of our Multi-Location & Franchise Operators series. If you're a restaurant franchisee, start with how restaurant franchisees can cut background check costs without cutting corners.
How does pay-per-check pricing actually work?
You pay a flat price each time you screen a candidate, with no subscription, platform fee, or minimum. If you hire nobody, you pay nothing.
Under a pay-per-check model, the order is the bill. A manager sends a check to a candidate, the candidate completes it, and that one report is charged against your card or your prepaid balance. You don't have to cancel anything when a store closes for renovation, and you don't have to renegotiate when you sell a unit.
When you compare per-check prices from different vendors, look at what the headline price includes. Advertised prices can grow once you add a separate charge for each county searched, a fee for identity verification, or a platform fee per seat. We covered where those extras come from in why you're paying $30+ per background check, and what you actually need. Use this test: if you screened one person tomorrow, what would the invoice say, line by line?
Ask every vendor these questions:
- Is identity verification included, or billed as an extra?
- Are there per-user, per-location, or monthly platform fees?
- What happens to the charge if the report can't be completed?
- Are there pass-through court fees, and are they listed in advance?
- Do prepaid credits expire, and can every location draw from them?
What are prepaid packs, and when do they beat paying one at a time?
A prepaid pack is credit you buy up front at a lower unit price, then spend on checks at any location. It beats paying one check at a time once you know you'll use the credit.
Packs sit between pure pay-as-you-go and a contract. You commit money, but you don't commit to a term or a monthly minimum. At PreHireBadge, the single-report price is $10, and prepaid packs are offered at $90, $400, $700, $900, and $1,000, as listed on the pricing page. The largest pack is the 200-check bundle, which works out to $5 a check. See the pricing page for the exact count in each smaller pack instead of estimating it.
For a multi-unit operator, packs are mainly a cash-flow and approval tool. You buy one pack at the corporate or ownership-group level and every location draws from it. Store managers can order without a card on file or an expense report. Finance sees one purchase and a running balance.
A sensible rule: run on single checks for one or two months, count what you actually used, and then buy a pack that covers roughly a quarter of that pace. You'll get the lower unit price without tying up cash in credit you won't use soon.
How do annual contracts and monthly minimums compare?
Contracts and minimums trade flexibility for a negotiated rate. They work when volume is steady and predictable. Per-check and pack pricing work better when volume swings.
Here is how the structures compare. It describes how each model works, not any specific vendor's prices.
| Factor | Pay per check | Prepaid pack | Monthly minimum | Annual contract |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commitment | None | The pack amount only | A fixed spend every month | A fixed term, often with volume tiers |
| Cost in a slow month | $0 | $0 new spend | The full minimum | Depends on the terms, sometimes a true-up |
| Unit price | Highest of the four | Lower as packs get bigger | Negotiated | Negotiated |
| Adding a location | Add a user | Add a user, same balance | May require an amendment | May require an amendment |
| Selling or closing a location | Nothing to cancel | Credit stays with the account | Minimum continues | Term continues |
| Budget visibility by store | Every charge is one check | Every draw is one check | Unused minimum isn't assigned to any store | Usually allocated after the fact |
Before you sign any contract, read three clauses: what happens if you use fewer checks than you committed to, whether the term auto-renews, and how much notice you have to give to leave. Those clauses, more than the unit rate, decide what the contract costs a fast-changing portfolio.
Worked example: what does each model cost a 12-unit operator?
Short answer: when hiring varies by store and by season, the unused part of a minimum can cost more than the per-check difference saves. Run your own numbers before you sign anything.
Every number below is an assumption chosen for illustration, not industry data. Replace each one with your own.
- Assumption: You operate 12 locations.
- Assumption: Eight mature stores each screen 4 candidates a month. Three slower stores each screen 1 a month. One new store screens 30 in its opening month and 4 a month after that.
- Assumption: A hypothetical contract vendor charges a $250 monthly minimum that covers a set number of checks at a negotiated rate. For simplicity, assume the minimum covers your usage in normal months.
Normal month: 8 × 4 + 3 × 1 + 4 = 39 checks. Opening month: 8 × 4 + 3 × 1 + 30 = 65 checks.
Pay per check at $10: a normal month costs $390, and the opening month costs $650.
Prepaid at $5 a check (the $1,000, 200-check bundle): a normal month uses $195 of credit, and the opening month uses $325. At 39 checks a month, one 200-check bundle lasts a little over five months.
Monthly minimum: under this made-up contract, a normal month costs at least $250. But now change one assumption. Say a holiday freeze cuts hiring to 10 checks in January. Pay-per-check costs $100 that month, and prepaid uses $50 of credit. The minimum still costs $250.
What this shows: the cheapest model depends on how much your volume swings, not on which unit price is lowest. If your total is steady and high, a well-negotiated contract may come out ahead. If store count, seasons, or openings move your numbers around, flexible pricing usually wins. Repeat the math with your real hiring counts from last year.
Should you run hiring centrally or let each location order?
Do both: set the policy and pay centrally, and let location managers order. That way checks go out quickly, and the rules and the spend stay controlled from one place.
A fully centralized model, where a home-office coordinator orders every check, gives you tight control but slows hiring. A shift lead's candidate waits until someone at headquarters gets to the request, and a good hourly candidate often takes another offer in the meantime. A fully local model, where every store has its own vendor and card, is fast but inconsistent: different vendors, different searches, and no one view of what you spend.
The hybrid works like this:
- Central: one account, one written policy, one payment method or prepaid balance, and a person who owns compliance.
- Local: each store or area manager has a login with the access the job needs. With team roles, a location manager can send invites without seeing billing or other stores' candidates.
- Shared view: one hiring board showing every candidate's screening status, so an area manager covering four stores sees what's stuck.
- Batch hiring: for openings and seasonal ramps, use bulk ordering to invite a whole class of hires at once instead of sending 30 invites one by one.
Put the policy in writing before you hand out logins. The free background check policy generator gives you a starting draft. Have counsel review it for each state you operate in.
How do you budget background checks by location?
Use a simple per-store forecast: expected hires, times candidates screened per hire, times your unit price. Then compare it with actual spend every month.
Here's the formula. Every input is yours to fill in:
- Estimate hires per location for the year. Use last year's new-hire count from payroll, not a guess. Add the expected opening crew for each planned new unit.
- Set your screens-per-hire ratio. If you only screen after a conditional offer, it should be close to 1. If candidates often drop out after the offer, track how often and adjust the ratio.
- Multiply by your unit price. Use $10 if you'll pay per check, or the effective rate of the pack you plan to buy. At the 200-check bundle, that's $5.
- Add a reserve for the openings and seasonal peaks you already know about, listed by month.
- Charge actual usage back to each store monthly. Per-check billing makes this easy, because each charge is tied to one candidate and one location.
- Review quarterly. A store whose screening spend jumps is usually a store with a turnover problem. That's worth knowing for reasons that have nothing to do with background checks.
The habit in step six is the hidden benefit of per-check pricing. Screening spend becomes a rough turnover gauge for each store. Under a flat contract you'd never see it.
For state-level context when you're planning expansion, see our hiring and background check statistics by state.
What changes when your locations span several states?
The price per check is the same everywhere, but the rules for when and how you may screen are not. Federal law applies everywhere, and many states and cities add their own timing and notice requirements.
The federal baseline is the Fair Credit Reporting Act. It governs how employers get and use reports from a consumer reporting agency, including disclosure, authorization, and the pre-adverse and adverse action steps before you reject someone based on a report. On top of that, a number of states and cities have fair-chance or "ban the box" rules. These can limit when in the hiring process you may ask about criminal history or run a check, often not until after a conditional offer, and they can add their own notice or individualized-review steps. Some local rules apply only to employers above a certain size, and others reach smaller businesses.
Laws in this area change often, and rules differ from city to city within the same state. This article doesn't list them, and you shouldn't rely on a vendor blog for them either. For each state and city where you operate, confirm the current rules directly with that state's or city's labor or human rights agency, or with employment counsel, and note the date each rule took effect.
What a multi-state operator can do:
- Use the strictest common process. If any of your markets require offer-first screening, running offer-first everywhere is usually the simplest way to stay consistent. Ask counsel whether that fits your markets.
- Keep the notices inside the workflow. When required notices and adverse action steps are built into the screening tool, a store manager in a new market can't skip them by mistake.
- Know the gaps in national data. National criminal databases are useful, but they don't cover every courthouse equally. Some states, New York in particular, have limited court data in national databases. If a role in one place needs certainty, budget for a direct court search there.
Retail operators with cash-handling roles should also read background checks for retail stores: screening cash-handling hires on a budget, which covers matching the search to the role.
Rollout checklist: switching every location to pay-per-check
Run this list once at the home office, then give each location the short version.
- ☐ Pull last year's new hires by location from payroll.
- ☐ Read your current vendor contract for minimums, auto-renewal, and the notice period to leave. Calendar the date.
- ☐ Write or update your background check policy, and have counsel review it for every state and city you operate in.
- ☐ Decide when in the process each location screens (for example, after a conditional offer) and make it the same everywhere unless a local rule says otherwise.
- ☐ List any roles or locations that need a search beyond a national database, such as a specific county or a New York statewide court search, and pick a source for those.
- ☐ Create one account and add each location manager with limited access.
- ☐ Decide between single checks and a prepaid pack, using the budget formula above.
- ☐ Set a monthly chargeback report by location.
- ☐ Train managers on what to do when a report shows possible records: no decision until the adverse action steps run.
- ☐ Give managers a free course link for refreshers. The PreHireBadge Academy has free courses on hiring and FCRA compliance.
How PreHireBadge fits a multi-location operator
PreHireBadge is built for pay-per-check screening: $10 a report, no subscription, and prepaid packs at $90, $400, $700, $900, and $1,000. The $1,000 pack is the 200-check bundle at $5 a check. There's no contract to sign and no monthly minimum, so a closed or sold store costs nothing.
What the report covers. One standard report runs a national criminal database search, each state's sex-offender registry, and federal lists such as OFAC sanctions and FBI Most Wanted. Clear reports usually come back the same day. A possible record is confirmed at the source within 72 hours. If it can't be verified, you get your money back instead of a guess. Details are on the national criminal check page, and record origins are on our sources page.
How ordering works. ScreenForge Labs is the FCRA consumer reporting agency behind the reports. Every order is an invite the candidate completes on their own phone, so your store managers never enter or store an SSN, date of birth, or address. Identity verification is included at no extra cost. Offer-first gates, required notices, and pre-adverse and final adverse action run inside the product. You can invite candidates in bulk or through the API. A candidate can share a 90-day status page showing their name, Clear or Records found, and dates. That page is not a consumer report, so don't use it to make a hiring decision in place of one.
What it does not cover. The standard report is not a search of every county courthouse. If a role needs certainty for one county, a clerk-of-court search there is the right tool, at a much higher price, and PreHireBadge doesn't offer it. New York state court data is limited in national databases, and an official New York statewide court search is not part of the standard report. PreHireBadge also does not offer motor vehicle records, drug testing, or employment-history verification. If a role needs any of those, such as delivery drivers or regulated positions, use a provider that offers them. You can see how we compare on the comparison page and the full feature list on how PreHireBadge works.
Try it at one location first. Open an account without a card, add one location manager, and run your next few hires at $10 each. If the process fits, add the rest of your stores and decide whether a pack makes sense. Create your free account.
Common questions
Is pay per background check always cheaper than a contract?
No. A contract with a low negotiated rate can cost less if your volume is high and steady and you always use your commitment. Pay-per-check usually wins when volume swings by store or season, or when your store count is changing. Run the worked example above with your own numbers.
Can all my locations share one prepaid pack?
With PreHireBadge, yes: buy at the account level and let each location draw from it. Team roles control who can order and who can see billing.
Do I need a different process in each state?
The ordering process can be the same everywhere. The legal steps around it, such as when you may screen, which notices you must give, and how you review a record, can differ by state and city. Many operators use the strictest common process. Confirm current local rules with the relevant agency or counsel.
What happens if a check comes back with a possible record?
PreHireBadge confirms possible records at the source within 72 hours, and refunds the check if it can't be verified. Don't make a decision until the report is final, and then follow the pre-adverse and adverse action steps, which run inside the product.
Does a national criminal search cover every county?
No. National databases don't include every courthouse, and coverage varies. If a role needs certainty for a specific county, order a clerk-of-court search there from a provider that offers it. PreHireBadge does not.
Where can I find more free tools?
The tools page includes the policy generator and other free hiring and compliance tools.
Sources
- International Franchise Association: Franchising Economic Outlook
- PreHireBadge pricing
- PreHireBadge national criminal check
- PreHireBadge data sources
This article is general information, not legal advice. Screening laws change and vary by state and city. Confirm current requirements with the relevant agency or your employment counsel before you act.




