Background Check Adjudication: How to Decide Fairly and Legally
Background check adjudication explained: what it means, how to build a hiring adjudication matrix, and how to apply it under FCRA and EEOC guidance.
standard employment reports
Invite a candidate, they verify their ID on their phone, and you get a national criminal report. Flat price, nothing monthly.
Get started See pricingIn this report
Background Check Adjudication: How to Decide Fairly and Legally

Background check adjudication is the step where a person at your company reviews a report that came back with something on it and decides, using written criteria, whether it affects the hire. The report supplies facts. Adjudication turns those facts into a documented, consistent decision. Done well, it protects candidates from unfair exclusion and protects you from claims of inconsistent or discriminatory treatment.
This guide covers what adjudication means, what “not adjudicated” signals, how to build a hiring adjudication matrix, which federal rules shape the process, and how to handle disputes and adverse action.
TL;DR
- Adjudication is the documented review of a flagged report against job-related criteria. It is not an automatic pass or fail.
- A matrix is a written guide that sets consistent starting points by offense type, age of the record and job duties. Use it as a guide, never as an automatic disqualifier.
- Federal guidance asks you to weigh the nature of the crime, the time elapsed and the nature of the job, and to let the candidate explain.
- Before you take adverse action based on a report, the FCRA requires the pre-adverse-action steps, including a copy of the report and a description of rights.
- Keep records of every decision. Consistency and documentation are your best defense.
Table of Contents
- What background check adjudication means in hiring
- What a background check adjudication matrix is
- The factors to build into your criteria
- The rules that shape adjudication
- Using a matrix without letting it decide for you
- Handling disputed or inaccurate results
- What this looks like by role
- Perspective: why adjudication should be built into the check
- Make the review step easier with PreHireBadge
- FAQ
- Sources
What background check adjudication means in hiring
Most reports come back clean and need no review. Adjudication applies to the ones that do not: a criminal record, a mismatch in identity details, an unverifiable item. The person adjudicating compares what the report says with what the job requires, then records a decision and the reason.
The word comes from government vetting, where trained adjudicators evaluate information to decide suitability or eligibility. In private hiring the idea is the same on a smaller scale: a trained reviewer, defined criteria, and a written outcome.
Two points shape everything that follows:
- The report does not make the decision. The screening company compiles records. You decide, and you own the decision.
- A record is not the same as a disqualification. The EEOC advises employers to assess how an applicant’s criminal history relates to the risks and responsibilities of the job, considering the nature of the crime, the time elapsed and the nature of the job.
What “not adjudicated” means
On a screening dashboard, “not adjudicated” generally means that nobody has reviewed the result and recorded a decision yet. The wording and workflow differ from platform to platform, so read your own system’s status definitions. It does not mean the candidate failed, and it does not mean the report is incomplete. It means a decision is still pending.
Many platforms label results in simple terms. One provider’s help page describes results as typically Clear or Consider, where Consider calls for review and may lead either to proceeding with the candidate or to starting the pre-adverse-action process. Adjudication is the review that sits behind that Consider label.
If a candidate’s status is sitting in a pending state, the fix is on the employer side: assign a reviewer, apply your criteria and record the outcome.
What a background check adjudication matrix is
An adjudication matrix, sometimes called an offense-decision matrix, is a written table your company creates before it screens anyone. It lists categories of findings and, for each, the factors and default handling that apply to different kinds of jobs. Its purpose is consistency: two candidates with similar records for the same role should get similar treatment, whoever happens to review them.

The EEOC says employers should treat applicants with similar criminal records consistently. A matrix is the practical tool for doing that at scale, especially when several people review reports.
A useful matrix has these parts:
- Finding category: for example violent offenses, theft or fraud, drug offenses, driving offenses, sex offenses, pending charges, and non-criminal discrepancies.
- Job risk tier: the duties that make the record relevant, such as handling cash, entering customers’ homes, driving, working with vulnerable people or accessing sensitive data.
- Look-back and age factors: how much weight the passage of time carries.
- Default action: proceed, proceed with a note, review further, or begin the pre-adverse-action process.
- Required follow-up: who reviews, what the candidate is asked and what gets documented.
A simple example layout
| Finding | Role relevance | Time factor | Starting point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Theft conviction | High for cash handling or access to customer property; lower for roles without either | Recent vs. many years ago | Individual review with candidate input |
| Driving offense | High for delivery or rideshare; low for desk roles | Recent vs. older | Review against driving duties |
| Arrest with no conviction | Not proof of conduct | Not applicable | Do not treat as proof; see below |
| Name or identity mismatch | Applies to all roles | Not applicable | Verify identity before any decision |
The last column says “starting point” on purpose. It is where the review begins, not where it ends.
The factors to build into your criteria
The strongest matrices borrow from public guidance rather than invent factors. New York City’s DCAS best-practices guide for public hiring identifies these factors when evaluating convictions: job duties, fitness for the duties, elapsed time, applicant age, seriousness and details of the offense, rehabilitation, and protection of people or property.
Translate those into questions your reviewer answers in writing:
- What does this job actually involve, and where would this offense create risk?
- How serious was the offense, and what were its circumstances?
- How long ago did it happen, and how old was the person?
- What has the person done since? Work history, training, references and completed sentences all matter.
- Is the record accurate, complete and current?
Red flags: arrests versus convictions
People often ask what counts as a red flag. The answer depends on the record type and the role. The EEOC draws a clear line: an arrest is not proof that the person committed a crime and may be inaccurate or incomplete, while a conviction generally gives stronger evidence but should still be checked for accuracy and currency before you rely on it.
In practice, treat these as items that need review, not as automatic rejections:
- A conviction directly related to the duties of the job.
- A discrepancy between what the candidate disclosed and what the report shows.
- Identity details that do not line up, such as a different name, date of birth or address history.
- A record that looks outdated, duplicated or already resolved.
The discrepancy between disclosure and report deserves a conversation before a conclusion. Honest errors in applications happen, and the candidate’s explanation is part of the evidence.
The rules that shape adjudication
Adjudication sits where three layers of law meet.
FCRA
The EEOC states that employers using background information must comply with federal nondiscrimination law, and those who use a company that compiles it must also comply with the FCRA. The same guidance says the employer must give a standalone written disclosure before obtaining a consumer report and get the applicant’s written permission.
The step that matters most for adjudication comes before a negative decision. A federal court opinion explains that the FCRA’s pre-adverse-action procedures give applicants time to respond before adverse action is taken. Before taking adverse action based in part on a consumer report, the employer must provide a copy of the report and a written description of the consumer’s rights.
When the decision is final, the notice has its own content. Law firm Fisher Phillips notes that a final notice should identify the reporting agency, state that the agency did not make the decision and cannot give specific reasons, and explain the applicant’s dispute rights and right to a free report within 60 days. For the mechanics and timing, see our guide to FCRA adverse action notices and common mistakes and the wider FCRA compliance guide for employers.
EEOC guidance
The EEOC warns against policies that create unjustified disparate impact and advises avoiding exclusions that significantly disadvantage a protected group without accurately predicting who will be responsible, reliable or safe employees. It also says applicants should have an opportunity to explain their criminal history and have the decision reevaluated in light of that explanation.
That last point is built into good adjudication: the matrix proposes, the candidate’s explanation informs, and the reviewer decides.
State and local fair-chance rules
The EEOC notes that state and municipal rules may add requirements, and that other federal, state or local laws may restrict or bar employment of people with certain records. Some jurisdictions require a sequence in which non-criminal screening is completed and evaluated before any criminal history is considered. Your matrix must be built per jurisdiction where you hire, not once for the whole country. Our page on fair chance compliance shows how we handle this inside the ordering workflow.
Using a matrix without letting it decide for you
The main risk of a matrix is treating it as a machine. Fisher Phillips advises using an offense-decision matrix only as a policy guide, not as an automatic disqualifier, because overreliance can conflict with FCRA pre-adverse-action requirements and create EEOC disparate-impact risk.
Here is a workable process:
- Confirm identity and accuracy. Make sure the record belongs to this candidate and is current.
- Classify the finding using the matrix categories.
- Match it to the job. Use the actual duties, not the job title alone.
- Apply the factors: seriousness, time elapsed, age at the time and evidence of rehabilitation.
- Write down a preliminary decision and the reasons.
- If it is negative, start pre-adverse action. Send the copy of the report and the rights summary, then wait a reasonable period for a response.
- Consider the response. Record the candidate’s explanation and what you did with it.
- Finalize and notify, or proceed with the hire.
An easy way to keep step 6 on track is our pre-adverse action response planner.
Keeping decisions consistent
- Use the same matrix and reviewers’ guide for every candidate in the same role.
- Train reviewers, and have a second person review any decision to reject.
- Log every decision with its reason, in the same format.
- Revisit the matrix when you add roles, change duties or enter a new state.
- Check your outcomes periodically for patterns you cannot explain by job-related factors.
Handling disputed or inaccurate results
Derogatory information is not a verdict. New York City’s DCAS guide says it does not automatically disqualify an applicant; the agency should explore the information and give the candidate an interview or a chance to submit a written statement. The same guide reflects the view that candidate explanations and evidence of rehabilitation are needed to understand whether the information truly bears on fitness for the specific position.
If a candidate says the report is wrong:
- Pause the decision and tell them how to dispute the item with the screening company. Our page on how candidates correct errors explains that path.
- Document the explanation or dispute and consider it.
- If the screening company corrects the report, Fisher Phillips advises that you use only the corrected or amended report for the decision.
An incomplete report is handled the same way: do not guess at the missing information. Wait for the completed result or ask the candidate for what is needed.
What this looks like by role
The same finding can lead to different outcomes depending on the job. A few illustrations of the reasoning, not rules:
- Delivery or rideshare driver: a recent serious driving offense is directly tied to the duties. A decades-old offense unrelated to driving is a weaker link.
- Cashier or retail associate: a theft or fraud conviction connects to handling money. A minor unrelated matter may carry little weight, especially if it is old.
- In-home service worker: offenses involving harm to people or property connect to entering customers’ homes, so the review is more careful.
- Remote office role: many offenses have little bearing on the duties unless the job involves sensitive data or finances.
To set the right scope before you order, our screening requirements by role tool helps match the search to the position.
Perspective: why adjudication should be built into the check
Most employers we talk to do not struggle to get a report. They struggle with what happens after it comes back: who reviews it, what the criteria are, which notice goes out and when.
Our view is that the compliance steps should not depend on someone remembering them. That is why we built adverse action handling, compliance documents and audit-ready evidence bundles into the product, and why every account gets compliance tracking at no extra charge.
We also believe a good matrix is short, written down and used as a guide. Pair it with a real conversation with the candidate and you get decisions that are consistent and defensible, without turning a $5 check into a legal project.
Matt
Make the review step easier with PreHireBadge
Adjudication works best when the report is reliable and the follow-up steps are already set up. PreHireBadge runs automated, FCRA-compliant checks: candidates verify identity with a government ID and a live selfie, and the search covers county, state and federal courts, sex offender registries and federal watchlists. Reports typically arrive the same day, at a flat $5 per report with no subscription, as stated on our site.

If a result needs review, the adverse action workflow is built in and free with every report, so notices and evidence are handled in one place. See pricing and Platform Access to get started.
FAQ
What does it mean when a background check is adjudicated?
It means a reviewer has examined the flagged results, compared them with the job’s requirements and recorded a decision. In government vetting the same word describes a formal suitability or eligibility determination. In private hiring it simply marks the review step between receiving a report and acting on it.
Do I need an adjudication matrix to run background checks?
No law we have found as a source requires a matrix, but it is a practical way to treat similar records consistently, which the EEOC encourages. Keep it short, use it as a starting point and never as an automatic disqualifier. State and local fair-chance rules may add steps you need to follow.
What are the disadvantages of adjudication?
The main risk is rigid, automatic decisions that ignore context. A matrix applied mechanically can conflict with FCRA pre-adverse-action requirements and create disparate-impact risk. The fix is individual review, candidate input and written reasons for each decision.
Can I reject a candidate because of an arrest?
An arrest alone is not proof that the person committed a crime, according to the EEOC, so it should not be treated like a conviction. Check what the record shows, how it relates to the job and whether local law limits its use. If you are unsure, talk to an employment attorney before acting.
What happens if the candidate disputes the report?
Pause the decision, point the candidate to the screening company’s dispute process and document their explanation. If the report is corrected, base your decision only on the corrected version.
Sources
- Criminal Records | U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
- Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know | U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
- Best Practices for Conducting Background Investigations | NYC DCAS
- Avoiding Hidden Hiring Landmines: 4-Step FCRA Compliance Plan | Fisher Phillips
- Wilson v. First Advantage Background Services Corp (2020) | FindLaw
- Background Checks FAQ | MangoApps Help





