Skip to main content
PreHireBadge
Guides

Arrest Records and Employment: What Employers Can Use

PreHireBadge TeamNovember 21, 202611 min read

What arrests, pending charges and convictions mean in hiring: what a background check shows, why records go missing, and how to stay FCRA-compliant.

standard employment reports

Invite a candidate, they verify their ID on their phone, and you get a national criminal report. Flat price, nothing monthly.

Get started See pricing

Arrest Records and Employment: What Employers Can Use

HR manager assessing a court record

An arrest is not a conviction, and hiring rules treat them very differently. Federal guidance says an employer cannot refuse to hire someone simply because they were arrested, though it may look into the conduct behind the arrest and let the person explain. The safest routine is to verify the candidate’s identity, search courts at every level, read each record for its outcome, and follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) steps before you reject anyone. We built PreHireBadge to automate those steps for employers and gig platforms.

Prehirebadge
Screen Candidates With Clearer Context
PreHireBadge verifies candidate identity and searches county, state, and federal courts, with reports typically delivered the same day.
Visit

TL;DR

  • An arrest record shows that someone was detained or charged. A conviction record shows a finding of guilt, a sentence or supervision. Employers should weigh them differently.
  • Many arrest records lack a final outcome, and records can be missing or wrong, so a result with no disposition needs follow-up before it drives a decision.
  • Before rejecting a candidate on a report, the FCRA requires written permission up front, then a pre-adverse notice with a copy of the report and the rights summary, then a final notice.
  • On October 29, 2026, the EEOC voted to rescind its 2012 arrest and conviction guidance. Title VII discrimination rules still apply, and state and local laws still apply.
  • Candidates can request their own report and dispute errors in writing.

Table of Contents

What counts as an arrest record and what counts as a conviction

The two terms sound close, but the law separates them. Wisconsin’s civil rights agency, for example, defines an arrest record as information that a person was questioned, apprehended, detained, held for investigation, arrested, charged, indicted or tried for an offense. A conviction record covers a conviction, a delinquency finding, a less-than-honorable discharge, probation, a fine, imprisonment or parole.

The practical difference is proof. An arrest says an officer or prosecutor believed there was cause to act. It does not say the person did anything. A conviction is a court’s finding. Pending charges sit in between: the case is open and no finding exists yet.

That is why the same name can return very different results on two reports. One shows a closed case with a conviction. Another shows a charge from three years ago with nothing after it.

Can you reject a candidate over an arrest or a pending charge?

The federal answer has two halves.

The arrest alone is not enough. The EEOC’s public guidance for job seekers says an employer cannot refuse to hire someone simply because they were arrested. It may, however, explore the conduct that led to the arrest and ask the person to explain.

Conviction history can be considered, with job relevance. The same page says that when judging relevance, employers should look at the nature and seriousness of the offense, the time since the offense or the end of the sentence, and the nature of the job. A policy that screens out many more applicants of one race, national origin or sex is discriminatory if it is not closely related to the job.

Three factors for assessing conviction relevance

The EEOC’s employer page adds that a screening policy can violate Title VII when it has a disparate impact and is not job related and consistent with business necessity. Disparate impact means a neutral-looking rule that falls harder on a protected group. The same page tells employers to apply the same standards to every applicant.

What changed in October 2026

On October 29, 2026, the EEOC voted to rescind its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on arrest and conviction records, effective immediately. The rescission does not require employers to drop lawful practices they adopted in response to it, and the agency’s chair said Title VII still prohibits race and national-origin discrimination. In practice:

  • Title VII still applies to how you use criminal history.
  • The FCRA is unchanged and is enforced separately.
  • State and local rules, which are often stricter, are unaffected.

The 2012 guidance had stated that an exclusion based on an arrest alone is not job related and that a conviction usually serves as sufficient evidence of conduct. Employers who built a consistent, documented process around that thinking have no reason to abandon it. For a plain-language walk-through of where employers stand now, see our note on what employers do now after the EEOC change.

State and local rules go further

Many states and cities restrict when and how you can use criminal history. Pennsylvania’s Attorney General explains that under the state’s criminal history records law, felony and misdemeanor convictions may be considered only to the extent they relate to suitability for the job, and written notice is required if the decision rests on that information. California has its own fair chance rules; one useful explainer covers working while on bail in California and how the Fair Chance Act treats pending cases. If you hire in several states, check the rule for each work location. Our fair chance compliance page describes how we build those steps into every check.

Federal jobs and federal contractors have another layer. With certain exceptions, they may not ask about criminal history until after a conditional job offer, according to the EEOC’s job seeker page.

Why records go missing, look incomplete or turn out wrong

Readers searching for missing criminal records usually have one of two worries: a real record did not appear, or a record appeared that should not have. Both happen, for structural reasons.

No single national file exists. Federal guidance for the Select Agent Program notes that no central repository holds federal, state and local criminal records, that not every state automates its data, and that no federal law sets standards for collecting and searching it. It recommends a broader multi-state check for completeness. A search that covers one county can miss a case filed in the next one.

Many arrests have no outcome attached. A Bureau of Justice Statistics report found that many arrest records lack a final disposition, meaning how the case ended. The EEOC’s 2012 guidance made the same point: arrest records may be inaccurate or keep being reported after expungement or sealing.

Online sources lag the courthouse. The Select Agent guidance advises verifying criminal history before adjudication, especially when it comes from online sources, and checking local court dockets because they hold set-asides and expungements that change the record.

What this means for a hiring decision:

  1. Treat a record with no disposition as a question, not an answer.
  2. Confirm the record belongs to your candidate, not someone with a similar name.
  3. Look for the current status: dismissed, sealed, expunged, convicted or pending.
  4. Give the candidate a chance to respond before you decide.

The consumer reporting rule that backs this up

When a screening company supplies public-record information likely to hurt a candidate, the FCRA requires it to do one of two things: notify the candidate when the information is reported, or keep strict procedures so the information is complete and up to date. The statute says an arrest, indictment or conviction counts as up to date if the current public record status is reported. In other words, a stale charge should not sit on a report as if nothing happened afterward.

How far back can a record go?

The FCRA limits how long some items can be reported, and non-conviction arrests are subject to a seven-year window under the statute. Convictions are generally not subject to the same cap under federal law, but many states set their own lookback limits, and sealing or expungement can remove a record from what you may use. Pennsylvania’s Clean Slate amendment, for instance, allows certain records to be sealed, including no-conviction records, summary offenses and many misdemeanors more than 10 years old. Our guide to how far back a background check goes breaks down the lookback question by record type.

The FCRA steps before you act on a report

If you screen through a consumer reporting company, the FCRA applies, and the FTC enforces it. The CFPB’s reentry handout lays out the sequence, and every step matters:

  1. Disclose and get written permission. Tell the candidate you may use a report and ask for written authorization before you obtain it.
  2. Send a pre-adverse notice. Before any adverse action, give the candidate a copy of the report and the document titled A Summary of Your Rights under the FCRA.
  3. Wait a reasonable period. Practitioners commonly use about five business days, which gives the candidate time to point out an error.
  4. Send the final adverse action notice. It must name the reporting company, state that the company did not make the decision, and explain the right to dispute the report and to request a free copy within 60 days.

The usual mistakes are skipping the waiting period, sending the notice without the report attached, and applying criminal history unevenly between candidates. Our guide to FCRA adverse action notices, timing and common mistakes goes through each one, and the full FCRA compliance guide for employers covers the rest of the process.

This is where doing it by hand costs the most. Each step needs a timestamp, a document and a record that it happened. Our adverse action workflow is built into every report, so the notices, the timing and the audit trail come with the check rather than from a spreadsheet. Our pre-adverse action response planner helps you plan what happens when a candidate answers.

A worked example

Say a gig platform onboards a delivery driver. The report shows a theft arrest from four years ago with no disposition listed.

  • Do not reject on the arrest alone. The arrest does not establish that the conduct happened.
  • Check the status. Is the case dismissed, pending or convicted? A court docket search can settle it.
  • Ask the candidate. Invite an explanation, since the EEOC says employers may explore the conduct behind an arrest.
  • If there is a conviction, weigh it. Consider how serious it was, how long ago, and how it relates to driving and handling customer property.
  • If you still decide to decline, run the two-step FCRA notices and keep the file.

The same record on a candidate for a warehouse job might be weighed differently, because the job is different. That is the point of a documented, job-related policy.

What candidates can do about a missing or wrong record

If you are the candidate, you have rights too. The CFPB advises you to request your own background screening report and check it for errors. When you give consent to a screening, ask for the screening company’s name if you can. To fix an error:

  1. Tell the screening company in writing. Certified mail is recommended, and send copies, not originals.
  2. Include supporting documents. You may need underlying records from the courthouse or state repository.
  3. Expect an investigation. The company generally has 30 days to investigate, sometimes 15 more, and must notify you within 5 business days of finishing.
  4. If the error stays, you can complain to the CFPB or FTC or file a lawsuit.

All of this comes from the CFPB’s handout. Our FCRA authorization and your rights page explains what you sign and what you are entitled to. If a case is still open or you need to clear a record, a criminal defense attorney in your state is the right person to ask; for example, one Massachusetts firm explains how to get your CORI report and when a lawyer helps.

Candidates who want to carry proof of a clean, verified check from job to job can look at our portable background check badge, a 90-day status badge.

Screening that matches what the law expects

If you hire employees or contractors, the screening itself should support the decisions above. We run our National Criminal Report with identity verification by government ID and a live selfie, then search county, state and federal courts, sex offender registries and federal watchlists. Reports typically come back the same day. The identity step is included at no extra cost, and it matters here because a match to the wrong person is how innocent candidates get hurt.

Pricing is per report with no subscription, and Platform Access is $0 per month. Bulk CSV upload, API and chat ordering are available, and compliance documents and audit-ready evidence bundles are included. See the pricing page or the national criminal check.

Prehirebadge

To see where the data comes from, read our data sources page. To match screening scope to the role, use the screening requirements by role tool.

Our perspective

Most hiring mistakes around arrest records come from two shortcuts: treating every hit as a conviction, and treating a clean report as proof that nothing exists. Both are process failures, not people failures.

We designed PreHireBadge around that. A candidate verifies identity with a government ID and a live selfie, so the record belongs to the right person. The search covers county, state and federal courts, sex offender registries and federal watchlists. Adverse action handling, compliance documents and audit-ready evidence come with the report, so the steps the FCRA requires are not left to memory.

We price per report with no subscription and no hidden fees, because a small employer or a gig platform should be able to screen consistently, every candidate and every time. Consistency is what keeps a policy fair and defensible.

Matt

FAQ

Do arrests show up on an employment background check?

They can. A court search can return arrests and charges as well as convictions, and the FCRA limits how long non-conviction arrests may be reported. Whether you may use one in a decision is a separate question, and an arrest alone is not a sound basis for rejecting someone.

Can an employer fire someone for pending charges?

Federal guidance says the fact of an arrest does not establish criminal conduct, but an employer may look at the underlying conduct if it makes the person unfit for the job. State law may limit this further, so check the rule where the employee works.

Why would a criminal record not appear on a check?

There is no single national repository, not every state automates its records, and some records lack a disposition. A check that searches only one county or one database can miss a case. Searching county, state and federal courts narrows that gap.

What should a candidate do about a wrong record?

Request your report, dispute the error in writing with the screening company, and attach supporting documents. The company generally has 30 days to investigate. If it is not fixed, you can complain to the CFPB or FTC.

Sources

Keep reading

Turn the research into a screening step.

Send a candidate an invite, they consent and verify their ID on their phone, and ScreenForge Labs furnishes a national criminal employment report for $10 flat. No subscription, and no SSN for you to handle.

Method
Drafted by PreHireBadge Research with AI-assisted search of public data. Figures that could not be matched to a published source were cut, and each remaining one links to where it came from. Found a mistake? Email support@prehirebadge.com and the report will be fixed.
Not legal advice
General information only. Neither PreHireBadge nor ScreenForge Labs is a law firm, and FCRA and state screening rules turn on the facts of each case. Ask an employment attorney about your own hiring process.